Theology and philosophy · 10 min read

The Monarchy of the Father and the Act of Giving

Gregory Nazianzen’s confession of one simple God opens a Bonaventurian question. How does the Father’s eternal giving make him this Person?

Faith seeking understandingAbout this emblem

In this study

The voice over the water

At the Jordan, water touches the human body of the Son. The Spirit descends like a dove, and the Father’s voice calls him beloved. The river bears a moment in history in which we can hear of a love that has no beginning. At the end of the Gospel, the risen Jesus entrusts his disciples with one name for baptism, the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Through water and a voice, the eternal order of the Persons comes within our hearing. Matthew 3:16–17 and 28:19

The monarchy of the Father names the order of origin within the divine life disclosed there. The Father has his divine life from no other Person. He eternally begets the Son and is the first origin of the Spirit. His firstness concerns who is from whom. The one divine life is underived in its being, and it belongs whole and entire to each of the three. Question 18 distinguishes the Father’s unbegottenness from this common divine independence, called aseity. That distinction allows us to speak of the Son as wholly God and wholly from the Father. The Monarchy of the Father

The distinction also puts the inquiry into participation to work. A creature receives its own finite existence from God and remains really distinct from its source in nature. The Son has from the Father the very same undivided divine nature. Each is a real way of being from another, and each must be understood according to the kind of actuality communicated. Given that the Son receives the whole divine life in being begotten, what does the Father’s giving explain about who the Father himself is? The Trinity investigation

Gregory’s confession of the one Godhead

In his Third Theological Oration, Gregory Nazianzen honors a “Monarchy that is not limited to one Person” and gives this unity its content through equality of nature, concord, and unity of motion. The Father, Son, and Spirit have one divine life and act with one divine power. Gregory can therefore say that the Son and Spirit are from the Father, “though not after Him.” The order of origin is real in their coeternity. Gregory also describes the Son’s being as common with the Father and received from him. Orations 29.2–3 and 30.11

In his farewell before the bishops in Constantinople, Gregory’s words “And the union is the Father” introduce an account of the personal order running from and toward the Father. He gives unity its highest sense where the Persons possess the same “simple nature” and the same essence. The Father is personally the source in that unity. The entire Godhead is equally the Son’s and the Spirit’s. Gregory’s account thus joins the direction of personal origin to the fullness of the one divine life. Oration 42.15–16

Gregory calls Father “the name of the Relation” in reply to opponents who ask whether the name signifies essence or action. Their second option would put the Son among produced effects. Gregory’s answer names the real relation in which Father and Son stand to each other and affirms their sameness of nature. An account centered on eternal giving must preserve what the name Father signifies. The further question concerns what realizes that relation as the Father’s own way of subsisting. Oration 29.16

Why the Father gives and why he is Father

Bonaventure takes up the explanatory question in his Commentary on the Sentences. He writes, “Generatio potius est ratio paternitatis quam e converso.” Generation gives the reason for paternity, the Father’s relation to the Son whom he begets. Origin explains the relation in the order of understanding. In distinguishing the Father’s divine being from his being this distinct Person, Bonaventure can call the exercise of paternity the completion of the Person. This completion concerns what makes the Father personally distinct. His divine being is from no one. Commentary on the Sentences I, distinction 27, part 1, article 1, question 2 and distinction 28, question 3

The Father’s unreceived fullness explains how he has the power to give the divine life. The exercise of that power explains his positive relation to the Son. Jordan Daniel Wood’s defense of Bonaventure takes up the objection that begetting requires a Father whose personal distinction is already complete. An actual giver is required from the outset. That requirement leaves open what makes this giver incommunicably Father, meaning that being Father of the Son belongs to him alone. Bonaventure’s distinction between the fullness of the source and the completion of his personal form makes room for the act of giving to do that explanatory work. Wood’s defense of Bonaventure

In Eternal Origin and Personal Subsistence, I ask what allows an act to explain the Father’s personal distinction. Question 16 calls the underlying claim Premise M. Each Person’s proper eternal origin fully accounts for what makes that Person distinct within the one divine life. The Father is the demanding case because he is himself the unoriginated source. The argument begins with the Persons and origins received in revelation and asks how the Father’s particular way of giving can realize the very paternity in which he subsists. Premise M · The constructive argument

How the act gives paternity its form

First, the giving is complete in its exercise. In John 5:26 the Father gives the Son to have “life in himself.” Augustine reads the giving as the begetting itself. The Son has the whole divine life in being eternally begotten. This answers a difficulty posed by Francisco Suárez, who contrasts a way toward an established reality with an act that abides. Coeternity by itself leaves the difficulty open. The decisive point is that what generation gives is fully possessed in its very exercise. The act is eternally fulfilled in the Son’s having life in himself. John 5:26 · Augustine, Tractates on John 22.10 · Suárez, De Deo uno et trino, treatise III, book VII, chapter 6, §12

Second, the giving has the giver’s own actuality. Aquinas says that a divine agent and his action are distinct in reason. Lateran IV identifies the Father as the one who begets and the whole simple divine substance as what he gives to the Son. The gift is fulfilled in the Son’s having that life in himself. The giving itself is the Father’s own act within the very life he wholly has. The actuality of the act is thus the complete divine actuality of the source. Aquinas, Summa theologiae I, question 41, article 4, reply 3 · Lateran IV, constitutions 1–2

Third, this complete act has a direction proper to the Father. The Son has the divine life from the Father. The Father has it from no one and gives it to the Son. These are opposed relations within one complete communication. The direction toward the Son belongs to what the act accomplishes, for it gives the Son the whole life he has from this source. In the source, this same direction is paternity. Since the act is already fulfilled and has the actuality of the giver himself, its direction is an abiding determination of that whole actuality in the order of personal distinction. It accounts for the Father’s incommunicable personal individuation, what makes him this Person. The direction of the act gives paternity its form

I argue that the Father’s giving explains what makes him this Person. A description of paternity can help us recognize the giver. The act of generation explains his distinction because its abiding direction toward the Son belongs to the Father’s own actuality. That real opposition is what paternity names. The whole undivided divine life is his, and the act by which he gives it to the Son constitutes him as Father.

The comparison with Aquinas

Aquinas gives a positive account of the same reality. Paternity considered as a relation has its intelligibility from generation. Paternity considered as constituting the Father is understood before his act, because an action requires a Person acting. On his account, paternity has the actuality of the divine essence and distinguishes the Father through its opposition to filiation, the Son’s relation to the Father. The Bonaventurian account grants that generation requires an actual giver. It appeals to the proper direction of his completed act to explain what makes him incommunicably Father. I argue for parity on this question. Both approaches can explain what makes the Father personally distinct within the one, fully actual divine life. The dispute concerns which consideration explains the Father as this Person. Aquinas, Summa theologiae I, question 40, articles 2 and 4 · The comparison in full

Common divine knowing tests the distinction. It has the whole divine actuality, and all three Persons know with the one divine intellect. It therefore supplies no opposed relation proper to the Father. The Father and Son’s one spiration, their shared relation of origin toward the Spirit, is real and internal to God. Its being shared is why it supplies neither of their individual personal forms. In the Catholic account the Father and Son are one principle of the Spirit, and the Son eternally has this from the Father. The Catechism recognizes the Eastern emphasis on the Father as first origin and the Spirit’s procession through the Son. Gregory names the Spirit’s own proceeding as his personal distinction. The argument about generation takes up the proper relation by which the Father is Father of the Son. Gregory, Oration 31.8–10 · Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§245–248 and 253–255

The one name

Gregory gives his hearers a confession to carry into baptismal life. “Each God because Consubstantial; One God because of the Monarchia.” The words belong together. The Son’s receiving from the Father is the way he possesses the very same life without measure. The Father’s firstness is the order of that eternal giving. Oration 40.41

When the Church speaks the one name at the font, the order disclosed at the river becomes the order in which the baptized are invited to live. The ear receives a word. Grace draws the hearer into the Son’s prayer, and the Spirit gives a creature the courage to call God Father. We receive at our created measure a share in the life the Son has whole and entire by eternal birth. The water bears the sign, and the one who heard the name can now speak it as a child. Manifestation and theophany · Romans 8:14–17

Sources and further reading

  • Scripture. New American Bible, Revised Edition. Matthew 3:16–17 and 28:19, John 5:26, and Romans 8:14–17. United States Conference of Catholic Bishops
  • Gregory of Nazianzus. Orations 29, 30, 31, 40, and 42. Translated by Charles Gordon Browne and James Edward Swallow. Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, second series, vol. 7, edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace (Buffalo, Christian Literature Publishing, 1894). Oration 29 · Oration 30 · Oration 31 · Oration 40 · Oration 42
  • Augustine of Hippo. Tractates on the Gospel of John, tractate 22, §10. Translated by John Gibb. Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, first series, vol. 7 (Buffalo, Christian Literature Publishing, 1888). Text
  • Fourth Lateran Council. Firmiter credimus and Damnamus, constitutions 1–2 (1215), Denzinger–Hünermann 800 and 804–805. English text
  • Bonaventure. Commentary on the Sentences I, distinction 27, part 1, article 1, question 2, and distinction 28, sole article, question 3, replies 1–2. Opera omnia I (Quaracchi, 1882). Distinction 27 · Distinction 28, p. 501
  • Thomas Aquinas. Summa theologiae I, question 30, article 2, reply 1, question 40, articles 2 and 4, and question 41, article 4, reply 3. Translated by the Fathers of the English Dominican Province, second revised edition (1920). Question 30 · Question 40 · Question 41
  • Francisco Suárez. De Deo uno et trino, treatise III, book VII, chapter 6, §12. Opera omnia I (Paris, Louis Vivès, 1856). Latin text
  • Wood, Jordan Daniel. “The Father’s Kenosis: A Defense of Bonaventure on Intra-trinitarian Acts.” Pro Ecclesia 30, no. 1 (2021). Article
  • Council of Florence. Laetentur caeli (1439), Denzinger–Hünermann 1300–1301, on the procession of the Spirit and the Son’s receiving from the Father. Latin text
  • Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§245–248, 253–255. Vatican text
More writingGo deeper in the projects